Pickleball Probably Isn’t As Good Of A Workout As You Think

Pickleball, a sport that combines elements of tennis, Ping-Pong, and badminton, has surged in popularity across the United States. Played with a paddle and a plastic ball with holes, it can be enjoyed indoors or outdoors and is known for its accessibility to a wide range of ages and skill levels. The game is played on a court that is a fraction of the size of a tennis court, which contributes to its appeal as a more intimate and social sport.

The growth of pickleball has been nothing short of remarkable. According to the Sports & Fitness Industry Association, the number of players in the U.S. grew by nearly 40 percent between 2019 and 2021. This spike in interest has led to a diverse demographic of players, with a significant portion being over the age of 55. However, the sport is not limited to older adults; it has also seen a rise in participation among younger players, including those under 24. The appeal of pickleball spans generations, making it a family-friendly activity that brings people together.

Many assume that pickleball is an excellent workout due to its active nature. The game is often perceived as a low-impact sport that provides moderate-intensity exercise, suitable for improving cardiovascular health and burning calories. Studies have suggested that playing pickleball can lead to improvements in blood pressure, cholesterol levels, and overall cardiovascular fitness. Despite these benefits, there is a growing debate about whether pickleball alone meets the recommended exercise goals for all individuals, particularly for those seeking a vigorous workout.



The Study: Evaluating Pickleball’s Effectiveness as a Workout

Research Origin and Methodology

As pickleball’s popularity surges, questions about its effectiveness as a workout have prompted researchers to take a closer look. Studies have emerged comparing the physical benefits of pickleball to other forms of exercise. One such study from Western Colorado University set out to quantify the cardiovascular and caloric impacts of playing pickleball. Participants were monitored for heart rate, calorie expenditure, and other health markers such as cholesterol levels and blood pressure. The methodology involved players engaging in pickleball sessions and comparing their physical responses to those elicited by other moderate-intensity exercises.

Comparison to Other Forms of Exercise

When juxtaposed with other activities, pickleball presents an interesting case. It is often likened to tennis in terms of movement and strategy, but with a smaller court and underhand serving, the intensity can vary. The Western Colorado University study found that pickleball players averaged a heart rate of 109 beats per minute and burned approximately 354 calories per hour. These figures place pickleball in the same category as hiking, yoga, and water aerobics, all recognized as moderate-intensity workouts. However, it’s important to note that these comparisons are based on general observations and can differ widely based on the individual’s level of play and intensity.

Interpreting the Data: Steps and Heart Rate Intensity

Interpreting the data from these studies requires a nuanced understanding of exercise intensity. The heart rate data suggests that pickleball can indeed provide a moderate-intensity workout, which is beneficial for cardiovascular health. However, the step count and overall movement may be less than what is found in more vigorous activities like running or competitive tennis. The caloric burn, while significant, may not meet the requirements for those seeking high-intensity workouts for weight loss or peak athletic performance.

Moreover, the heart rate intensity observed in pickleball players indicates that while the sport can elevate heart rates to a level that is beneficial for improving cardiovascular fitness, it may not be sufficient for those aiming to achieve vigorous activity levels as recommended by some health guidelines. The American Heart Association, for example, suggests at least 150 minutes per week of moderate-intensity aerobic activity or 75 minutes per week of vigorous aerobic activity for overall cardiovascular health.

In conclusion, while pickleball does offer health benefits and can be a fun and engaging form of exercise, it may not be the comprehensive workout that some enthusiasts believe it to be. It is a sport that can be tailored to various fitness levels, but those seeking a more intense workout may need to supplement their pickleball games with additional forms of exercise.



Analyzing the Results: Moderate Exercise for Some, Insufficient for Others

Impact on Middle-aged and Older Adults

For middle-aged and older adults, pickleball appears to offer a moderate level of physical activity. The study conducted by the University of Manitoba found that players in this demographic reached a mean heart rate of about 111 beats per minute during play, which falls into the moderate-exercise range. This is particularly significant given that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) defines moderate activity as reaching 70% of the maximum predicted heart rate. With players spending approximately 40% of their time in this heart rate intensity zone, pickleball can contribute to the recommended 150 minutes per week of moderate exercise for older adults. However, it’s important to note that to meet these exercise guidelines, a substantial time commitment to the sport—around 4.5 hours per week—is required.

Implications for Younger and More Active Individuals

While pickleball does provide some level of physical activity, the implications for younger and more active individuals are less clear. The study suggests that for those who are already in good shape, pickleball may not offer the same level of challenge as other forms of vigorous exercise such as jogging or fast-paced cycling. The heart rate data indicates that the sport reaches vigorous levels of activity only about 30% of the time for many players. This may not be sufficient for younger individuals who seek more intense workouts to maintain or improve their fitness levels. Consequently, these individuals may need to supplement pickleball with other forms of exercise to achieve a comprehensive workout regimen.

Vigorous Activity Metrics in Pickleball

When assessing the vigorous activity metrics in pickleball, it’s important to consider the nature of the sport. Pickleball involves bursts of quick movement and shorter points, which can lead to sudden increases in heart rate. However, due to the smaller court size and the strategic nature of the game, there may be less continuous vigorous activity compared to sports like singles tennis. The accelerometer data from the study showed that players averaged fewer steps per hour than during an average hour-long brisk walk. This indicates that while pickleball can reach vigorous levels at times, it may not sustain those levels long enough to be considered a vigorous workout throughout the duration of play. Therefore, while pickleball can be part of a healthy lifestyle, especially for middle-aged and older adults, it should be complemented with other forms of exercise to meet the full spectrum of physical activity guidelines.



Pickleball’s Social and Community Impact

Growth During the Pandemic

The COVID-19 pandemic has reshaped many aspects of our lives, including how we exercise and socialize. Pickleball, a sport that combines elements of tennis, badminton, and ping-pong, has experienced a significant surge in popularity during this time. With its smaller courts and the ability to maintain social distance, pickleball became an ideal outdoor activity. The sport’s accessibility and social nature attracted many who sought safe ways to stay active and connect with others. As a result, the number of pickleball players grew exponentially, with the Sports & Fitness Industry Association reporting a 159% increase over three years to 8.9 million players in 2022.

Community Tensions and Court Conversions

However, the rapid expansion of pickleball has not been without its challenges. The sport’s distinctive “pop” sound, created by the paddle striking the plastic ball, has become a point of contention in some communities. Residents living near pickleball courts have raised concerns about noise, leading to disputes and even legal action in some cases. Additionally, the conversion of tennis courts to accommodate pickleball has sparked frustration among tennis players, who feel their space is being encroached upon.

Infrastructure and Resource Challenges

With pickleball’s popularity outpacing the availability of dedicated courts, infrastructure and resource challenges have emerged. Public parks and recreation departments are grappling with how to balance the needs of different user groups with limited space and funds. Some residents have pushed back against the conversion of multi-use spaces into pickleball courts, citing reduced areas for children to play and the sport’s dominance over other activities. Despite these challenges, the sport’s governing bodies and enthusiasts are advocating for thoughtful planning and sound mitigation strategies to foster a more harmonious coexistence within communities.

Pickleball’s social and community impact is multifaceted. While it has provided a much-needed outlet for physical activity and social interaction during the pandemic, it has also introduced new challenges in terms of community relations and public space management. As the sport continues to grow, it will be essential for players, residents, and local authorities to work together to address these issues and ensure that the benefits of pickleball can be enjoyed by all.



Meeting Exercise Guidelines with Pickleball

Recommended Exercise Goals

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommends that adults engage in at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic activity or 75 minutes of vigorous-intensity activity per week. Moderate-intensity activities are those where you can talk but not sing during the exercise, while vigorous activities are more taxing and include exercises like jogging and fast-paced cycling. Pickleball, with its combination of tennis, badminton, and table tennis elements, can provide a moderate workout, especially for middle-aged or older individuals.

Time Investment for Adequate Physical Activity

According to recent studies, playing pickleball can help individuals meet their physical activity guidelines if they invest enough time. For pickleball to count towards the recommended exercise goals, players would need to engage in the sport for approximately 4.5 hours per week. This is based on the average steps and heart rate intensity measured during game play. While singles play tends to be more intense than doubles, both formats can contribute to achieving the necessary exercise quota when played for sufficient duration.

Alternatives to Pickleball for a Comprehensive Workout

While pickleball can be a fun and engaging way to get moderate exercise, it may not be sufficient for younger or more active individuals seeking a vigorous workout. For those looking to diversify their exercise regimen or increase the intensity, alternatives could include:

  • Jogging or Running: These activities offer a higher calorie burn and can be more cardiovascularly demanding.
  • Swimming: A full-body workout that is also low-impact, making it suitable for a wide range of fitness levels.
  • Cycling: Whether outdoor or indoor, cycling can be scaled up to a vigorous intensity workout.
  • High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT): Short bursts of intense exercise followed by rest periods, known for high calorie burn in a shorter time frame.
  • Strength Training: Complementing aerobic activities with resistance exercises can improve muscle strength and metabolic rate.

Ultimately, the best exercise program is one that is well-rounded, including both aerobic and anaerobic activities, and is tailored to an individual’s fitness goals and preferences. Pickleball can certainly be part of a healthy lifestyle, but it should be complemented with other forms of exercise to ensure a comprehensive approach to fitness.



The Future of Pickleball Amidst Health Benefit Concerns

Potential Impact of the Study on Popularity

Recent studies questioning the efficacy of pickleball as a comprehensive workout have stirred debate within the fitness and sports communities. While the sport has seen a meteoric rise in popularity, particularly among older adults, the revelation that it may not meet vigorous activity metrics could potentially dampen its growth. However, the social and community benefits of pickleball, such as fostering connections and combating isolation, remain undeniable. The sport’s low barrier to entry and the joy it brings to players are likely to sustain its popularity, even if some may seek additional exercise forms to supplement their physical activity needs.

Adapting Pickleball for Greater Health Benefits

As a response to the study, there is an opportunity for the pickleball community to adapt the game for enhanced health benefits. This could involve structured training sessions focusing on agility and strength, or the introduction of more dynamic playing styles that increase cardiovascular intensity. Additionally, educational programs could be developed to inform players about the importance of incorporating a variety of exercises into their routines to achieve a balanced workout.

Community and Policy Responses to the Study

The study’s findings have prompted a call to action among local communities and policymakers. In places like Spokane, there is a push for the construction of public pickleball complexes, which would not only make the sport more accessible but also serve as hubs for health and wellness education. These complexes could offer programs that encourage physical activity beyond pickleball, such as fitness classes and nutritional workshops. Moreover, the potential for public-private partnerships could lead to the development of facilities that cater to a broader demographic, ensuring that the health benefits of pickleball and other activities are available to all.

Ultimately, the study may serve as a catalyst for a more holistic approach to community health, leveraging the popularity of pickleball to engage individuals in a wider array of physical activities. By doing so, communities can foster an environment where sports and recreation are not only about competition but also about well-being and quality of life.



Conclusion: Balancing Enjoyment and Health in Sports

Summary of Pickleball’s Health Efficacy

Pickleball has surged in popularity, particularly among older adults, due to its accessibility and the perception that it provides a good workout. While it does offer a range of health benefits, such as improved mood, cardiovascular health, hand-eye coordination, and social interaction, it may not be the rigorous workout many assume it to be. The game’s moderate intensity makes it a joint-friendly option that can contribute to overall health, but it may not meet the vigorous activity metrics necessary for younger or more active individuals seeking a high-intensity workout.

The Role of Enjoyment in Sustaining Exercise Habits

One of the key factors in maintaining a consistent exercise routine is enjoyment. Pickleball’s fun and social nature can significantly contribute to regular participation, which is crucial for long-term health benefits. The game’s appeal lies in its ability to foster community, provide a sense of accomplishment, and offer a competitive yet accessible environment. For many, the pleasure derived from playing pickleball can lead to a more active lifestyle, proving that the value of an exercise is not solely measured by its intensity but also by the likelihood of it being sustained over time.

Final Thoughts on Choosing the Right Exercise

When selecting the right form of exercise, it’s essential to consider both the physical benefits and the enjoyment factor. Pickleball may serve as a gateway to more active living for those who are sedentary or as a low-impact option for older adults. However, for those seeking a comprehensive workout, it should be complemented with other forms of exercise that address cardiovascular endurance, strength training, and flexibility. Ultimately, the best exercise is one that aligns with your fitness goals, accommodates your lifestyle, and, most importantly, is one that you look forward to engaging in regularly. Pickleball, with its unique blend of health benefits and enjoyment, can be a valuable part of a balanced exercise regimen.


READ MORE:  Brain & Body: Mental Health Benefits Of Exercise